Technology

External Audit

For any business, trust in financial reporting is the bedrock of its relationships with investors, creditors and partners — that’s why the requirement for external audits has become a given. Its the way big businesses prove to the world that the numbers and financial information they’re presenting are above board. And an external audit is no mere formality, it’s a vital tool for shining a light on any weak spots in a company’s accounting, risk management, and even its overall operations.

What is an External Audit

An external audit is when an independent team of people — not connected to the day-to-day goings-on at the company — review a business’s financial statements to make sure everything adds up. In other words, external auditors are the third party who gets to say whether the financial information a company’s presenting is any good. They do this by collecting and evaluating evidence to make sure that financial statements are truthful. In other words, that they don’t contain any big mistakes or deceptions. In doing this work they’ll be looking at all sorts of things, including account balances and all the information that has to be disclosed.

This type of audit gives stakeholders some confidence that the financial statements are all above board. Not 100% confident, but enough to give them some peace of mind. And if there are any concerns, an external audit report will spell them out for everyone to see. Its this report that lets stakeholders know whether the company’s operations are being properly monitored and controlled and whether its being transparent in all its dealings.

What’s the Difference between Internal and External Audits

Internal audits are done by people already working on the inside. They’re all about making sure things run as smoothly as possible and that the company’s in control. Internal and external auditors do different jobs. Internal audit is focused on making things better and more efficient, while an external audit is all about getting an independent view of how things really are. In other words, whether a company is really doing a good job or not.

External audits are often called for by investors or regulators, they’re looking for proof that a company’s being run properly and is being transparent in all its dealings. External audits give stakeholders that independent view. The view that says whether a company is really living up to its promises.

Both internal and external audits are super important. The internal controls that are put in place really help support the external audit. After all, they’re the ones that are setting things up right so the auditors can do their thing.

Standardize work with clear checklists and instructions Ensure consistent execution, reduce errors, and be audit-ready with ProcessNavigation. Try it free

External Audit Benefits

An external audit helps you and your stakeholders:

  • Credibility: An outside check by public accounting firms builds trust with investors, lenders and customers.
  • Regulatory Compliance: Makes sure you follow accounting rules. This helps you avoid fines.
  • Risk Management: Finds problems like waste, fraud and bad management. It helps fix them.
  • Informed Decision Making: Gives you facts for future plans. This helps make your work better and cost less.
  • Transparency: Makes your reports more open and honest.

A good outside check of financial records shows that your financial accounting is sound and follows the rules.

Objectives of External Audit

External audits aim to achieve:

Focus areaPurpose
Accuracy and integrityEntity’s financial statements are free from material misstatements, whether intentional or unintentional, and follow frameworks like GAAP or IFRS.
Compliance verificationFollow laws, regulations and contracts.Find any non-compliance and suggest actions to fix it.
Risk identificationDetects financial or operational risks that may affect financial performance or reputation.
Stakeholder assuranceProvide financial audit to stakeholders.
Enhanced governanceOffer ways to strengthen internal controls and governance. Internal control is key to protect company assets and to ensure work is done well.

External Audit Process: Steps

The external audit process is based on strict standards — ISA, PCAOB, AICPA, and the Sarbanes–Oxley Act for publicly traded companies.

How to perform an external audit

It consists of several sequential steps that guide external auditors in maintaining integrity and precision.

StageContent
1. PlanningWorking out what the goal is, thinking about how you’re going to get there, and hammering out a plan to check that nothing’s been fudged. That’s basically what the lead auditor does, especially when it comes to risk management. He or she figures out how big the company is and how complicated its operations are, and then puts together a plan that’ll help them do a proper job.
2. Getting to the bottom of thingsThe auditor trawls through the company’s records to get some solid facts and figures. They do this through various tests and inquiries, not just looking at the numbers, but also talking to management and seeing what’s going on.
3. Analysis and interpretationThe auditor has to sift through all this data, question some of the assumptions that’ve been made along the way, and keep a healthy dose of skepticism about the whole thing including what management are telling them.
4. Preparing an audit report (opinion)The auditor then decides what their verdict is going to be: a clean bill of health, a few reservations, a real problem, or they basically can’t say one way or the other. All of this gets put together in a report that sums up their view on just how reliable the figures are.
5. Communication with those charged with governanceThe auditor then shares all this with the people in charge of running the company and the audit committee often they’ll get a response back, especially from senior management.

External auditors must maintain independence, apply professional judgment and document every stage of audit work to meet compliance requirements and international expectations.

External Audit Opinions

External audit opinions summarize findings and clarify what users can expect from entity’s financial statements.

  • Unqualified Opinion: Financial statements are accurate and comply fully with standards.
  • Qualified Opinion: Some things are wrong. But for the most part, financial statements are true and fair.
  • Adverse Opinion: Big mistakes or rules were broken. Financial statements are not true and fair.
  • Disclaimer of Opinion: Given when auditors can’t form a view. They did not have enough proof. Or they could not see all the facts.

These views are very important for publicly traded companies. Trust from people who invest rests on audit results that are clear and fair.

What is an External Auditor?

An external auditor is a person from outside with the right skills and power to do an audit. They do many kinds of audits — from financial statement audits to checks on compliance and performance. In the world, this means having a title like CPA (USA), ACCA (UK), or CA (Canada, Australia).

Most auditors have a school degree in a field like finance. This helps them get a solid grasp of reports and risk. The role of an external auditor is to be a fair link between a firm and the people who use its financial reports.

These people make sure the facts given to investors and rule makers are right. Some external auditors work for large firms. Others work for themselves with small or mid-size firms. No matter how they work, they must follow strict rules. They must use professional skepticism and show good skill at solving problems to find issues and risk.

External Auditor Duties and Responsibilities

External auditors are responsible for:

  • Giving a high level of assurance. Auditors don’t promise that financial statements are 100% free of mistakes. But they give a strong belief that they are right (about 95–99%).
  • Being fair and independent. This means not having money in the firms they check.
  • Following the law and good work rules.
  • Keeping facts secret. Audit information cannot be shared without permission (unless the law says they must).
  • Finding big mistakes (material misstatements), whether from an error or fraud.
  • Acting first to find problems before they get big.

The jobs of an auditor and a manager are clear: managers make and own the financial statements. Auditors give their view on them. They have different jobs, but they need each other. This helps a company be open and responsible.

What do External Auditors Do during an Audit?

External auditors play a vital role. They go through a company’s financial statements with a fine-tooth comb. Every working day for an external auditor is spent planning, collecting evidence, testing and reporting. They follow strict guidelines that come from places like ISA, PCAOB and AICPA — there’s not a lot of room for deviation there. But that close, outside look at a company’s finances gives its stakeholders a true picture of just how a business is doing with its money.

Audit of Company Assets

Auditors go over every single thing a company owns — cash, stock, equipment, buildings, accounts it hasn’t been paid yet, and its investments.

For example, if they’re auditing equipment at a factory, they’ll be going over the records to make sure they match what’s actually there. They’ll check to see if the company’s accountants are correctly applying depreciation, and if they are correctly accounting for when something goes bad – like three machines that haven’t been used in two years but are still on the balance sheet. Its likely that they should be written off or revalued.

This all ties into the external audit definition, giving the people who matter a good idea that the records are accurate enough.

Audit of Liabilities

For instance, if they’re looking at accounts payable — the money a company owes to its big suppliers — they might send off letters to ask suppliers if they agree with what the company says they owe. And in a few cases, the suppliers said no they didn’t owe that much, and it turned out the company had just plain forgotten to add a bunch of invoices to the end of the year.

Income and Expense Review

Auditors also want to make sure a company is getting its revenue — or income — right, and that it’s accounting for its expenses correctly.

For example, an online store thinks it’s got the right idea when it recognizes revenue the minute a customer puts in an order. But auditors are there to tell them that’s not right. The revenue should be recognized when the goods are actually shipped to the courier. And in this case, the company had to go back and recalculate its revenue, which ended up reducing its profit for the year by a pretty significant 4%.

Business Process Testing

Auditors also want to make sure that key processes are actually running the way they’re supposed to within the company.

To do this, with the purchasing process, for example, they might pick 30 random transactions and check to make sure that every single one of them was approved, and that the department did the right thing, and that the supplier was properly vetted and the contract was signed off by lawyers, and that the price was right, and that the goods actually showed up in the warehouse, and that all the right documents were done.

In a few cases, they found that the company had sort of bent the rules, which was a sign of weaker controls.

External audits have started to use data a lot more. Not only does this make it easier to find problems but it also makes the financial records much more accurate.

When it comes to writing the auditor’s report, you have to take a close look at whether the company is a going concern. Is it still viable? Any worries you might have are expressed in the report.

And whether or not the company is a going concern, auditors are also going to report on the key audit matters (KAMs) — the big issues that required a lot of professional judgement to deal with. This all helps investors to get a feel for which bits of the company are the most high-risk.

Independence and Objectivity

Benefits of external audit

The basis of external audits is independence and objectivity. An external auditor’s job is to stay away from personal, money or other conflicts of interest. External auditors must be fair. This gives true external audit results to investors, regulators and other groups.

Independent accounting firms and third-party audit teams have rules to maintain their independence. This objectivity makes external audits different from internal reviews and ensures the findings can be trusted.

Audit Committee

In big companies, it is key for the audit committee to oversee the work. The audit team is led by the senior auditor. The team reports to the board all key findings such as KAMs. The committee ensures internal audits support external audits, reviews internal control analysis and validates that recommendations are implemented.

PCAOB vs. AICPA/ISA

StandardsApplies toFeatures
PCAOBPublicly traded companies in the United StatesStrict supervision, focus on investor protection.
AICPA (GAAS)Private companies (non-issuers)Flexible approach, emphasis on process efficiency and improve operational efficiency
ISAInternational projectsUnified rules applied globally, enhancing financial accounting quality and consistency in the reporting process

Despite the differences, the goal is the same: to form an opinion on the reliability of reporting and to build trust in business.

Challenges

External audit has its challenges:

  • Cost: Good auditors can be expensive. This is hard for small companies.
  • Time: Audits require a lot of work from the auditor and management.
  • Hard to Do: It’s hard for big companies to follow all the regulatory standards and accounting rules.
  • Conflict of Interest: It’s hard to maintain independence when working with clients for a long time.
  • Answering the Audit: You need good record keeping to give quick and true answers to auditor questions.

Best Practices for a Successful External Audit and Internal Controls

To get the most from an external audit:

  • Keep Good Records: When your financial records are up to date, the audit goes faster.
  • Hire Good Auditors: Choose auditors from a reputable independent accounting firm. Or pick ones who know your industry.
  • Be Open: Talk to the audit team.
  • Address Recommendations: Act on audit findings to improve operational efficiency.
  • Use Technology: Leverage modern tools for financial accounting and reporting workflow automation.
  • Be Proactive: Identify issues before audit cycles to reduce errors and risks.

An external audit is more than just a requirement. It is a smart tool to ensure your money is right, you have compliance and key people trust you. By looking at financial statements and internal controls from outside, an external audit builds trust and clarity. This helps you grow. It can be hard but the good parts are more than the cost. It’s a must for any company that wants to last long. Use the best to get the most from an external audit. You can turn it into an opportunity to grow and get better.

FAQ

The time it takes for an external audit really comes down to the size of the company and the scope of the external audit requests you’ve got. Small companies: we’re talking 3–4 weeks. Mid-size companies: that’s usually 6–8 weeks. Big companies: it can take 10–14 weeks to get it all done. Public companies: then you’re looking at 12–16 weeks. Over that period, the external auditors will be going through the company’s financial reporting to make sure it all adds up according to the accounting standards. They’ll also be reviewing the internal policies and making sure the internal controls are up to scratch to stop any errors creeping in. That means they’ll be testing documents, having a chat with the staff and having a look around the departments to make sure everything is running smoothly and following the rules.

The simple answer to that is no. External auditors can only give you a reasonable assurance, not a 100% guarantee. They’re looking at the financial reporting to see if it meets the accounting standards, checking to see if the internal policies are being followed consistently and whether the controls are in place to meet the regulatory requirements. What they’re doing is performing some risk-based tests and reviews, but that doesn’t mean every single dodgy deal will be uncovered. The final verdict is in the auditor’s report, which is based on the expert opinion of the auditor after reviewing all the evidence.

A tax audit, that’s one performed by the tax office. They’re mainly looking to see if the tax calculations, filings and payments are all up to scratch, and if not, what the consequences are. An external audit, on the other hand, is done by a private audit firm. They’re looking at the overall state of the financial reporting, against the accounting standards, not just the taxes. They’ll also be reviewing the internal policies and controls to give a bit of peace of mind to the investors, banks and other stakeholders out there with an interest in the business. Some key differences: A tax audit is a must, an external audit on the other hand is usually optional. The tax office is looking for rule breakers, the external auditors are wondering if the reporting and the controls are up to scratch. A tax audit can result in you getting landed with an additional bill or a fine, but an external audit just gives you an auditor’s report.

Materiality is just a fancy way of saying, is an error big enough to actually make a difference to the people reading the financial statements? External auditors use this concept when they’re reviewing the reports and ultimately deciding what to put in the auditor’s report. So if they find an error that’s below their materiality threshold, that’s just not worth worrying about. But if it’s above that level, then it’s considered a big deal and needs to be sorted out. Materiality is pretty handy for defining how the internal audits can help the management by focusing on the biggest risks out there. They usually work it out as a percentage of a key financial figure: 0.5-1% of sales 1-2% of total assets 5-10% of profit

Audit committees go through a quality review of the external auditors. That’s a set process that checks if the auditor is independent, how much work they’ve done and how good their reports are.

Standardize processes and be prepared for any audit ProcessNavigation helps companies create transparent, understandable, and repeatable operational processes. Get started for free
All articles
Table of Contents
Latest articles
More insights